Articles - Ordinateurs old school

Benchmarks : CompactFlash, DOM ou carte SD ?

|    |   1227  |   Commentaires (2)  |  Ordinateurs old school
Lorsque j'avais montré en vidéo que je remplaçais certains HDD de mes vieux PC par des cartes CompactFlash, certaines personnes dans les commentaires m'avaient proposé comme solution la carte SD. De plus, j'avais eu connaissance de l'existence des DOM après la lecture de divers blogs. Si vous ne voyez pas de quoi je veux parler, il serait plus sage pour vous de consulter cette page avant de continuer. J'ai voulu donc un peu tester tout ça afin de déterminer quelle serait la solution idéale entre les trois. Quelle serait la plus économique, la plus rapide, la plus facile et la plus fiable pour substituer un vieux disque dur dans un ancien ordinateur ?

Les tests



Pour faire ma propre idée, j'ai utilisé 4 PC x86 de ma collection de vieux PC, en partant du 486 jusqu'au Pentium 4, pour voir comment cela se goupille.



Ces tests restent simples et faits avec les choses que j'avais sous la main, je ne suis pas expert en benchmarks. Nous aurons en compétition pour les 4 PC à chaque fois 5 supports de stockage :

  • Une carte CF Transcend 4Go 133x "normale"
  • Une carte CF Cisco (Unigen rebadgée) 2Go "industrielle" (UGB30STC2000Z4)
  • Un DOM Kingspec Industrial 4Go (livré pré-formaté en FAT32, 3.66Go utilisables)
  • Une carte SDHC Samsung 16Go EVO sur KTC FC1307A.
  • Une carte SDXC Transcend 64Go 300x 45MB/s sur KTC FC1307A.


Les 2 cartes SD ont été reformatées en une partition primaire de 8Go - 8032Mo pour la compatibilité avec les BIOS/DOS.



Les logiciels utilisés



  • PC Windows : ATTO Disk Benchmark 2.41
  • PC Windows : DiskSpeed32
  • PC Windows : Roadkil's Disk Speed Version 2.0
  • PC Windows : IDEdrive 2.0 de Robert Smid
  • PC 486 sous DOS : System Speed Test 32 4.78


PC de test n°1 - Génération Pentium



Je vais partir de ce PC car c'est le premier qui j'ai converti à la sauce CF. Il va me servir de point de départ pour cette expérience.




Description



  • PC Zenith Z-Station EL
  • Intel Pentium 233 MMX
  • 64Mo de RAM
  • Chipset : Intel 430VX Triton II / PIIX3 - 82371SB
  • Nappe IDE : 40 fils
  • Windows 98 Deuxième édition 4.10.2222A
  • Configuration BIOS : IDE tout en automatique (PIO, DMA, etc...)
  • Configuration Windows : Mode DMA activé


Carte CF Transcend



IDEdrive 2.0 :

PRIMARY MASTER :
List output by standard : ATA-5
[Word 0] General configuration :
Type of device : Not specified
Removable media device : Yes
Not removable controller and/or device : No
[Word 1] Number of logical cylinders : 7769
[Word 3] Number of logical heads : 16
[Word 6] Number of logical sectors per logical track : 63
[Word 10-19] Serial number : A678011B09220F00010B
[Word 21] Cache size : 1 KB
[Word 23-26] Firmware revision : 20110407
[Word 27-46] Model number : TS4GCF133
[Word 47] Maximum number of sectors per interrupt : 1
[Word 49] Capabilities :
Stanby timer values supported : No
IORDY supported : Yes
IORDY may be disabled : Yes
[Word 54] Number of current logical cylinders : 7769
[Word 55] Number of current logical heads : 16
[Word 56] Number of current logical sectors per track : 63
[Word 57-58] Current capacity in sectors : 7831152
[Word 59] Current number of sectors per interrupt : 1
[Word 59] Multiple sector setting is valid : Yes
[Word 60-61] Total number of user addressable sectors (LBA mode) : 7831152 (4.010 GB)
[Word 63] Multiword DMA transfer mode active : None
[Word 63] Multiword DMA transfer mode supported : 2 (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 64] Advanced PIO transfer mode supported : 4 (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 65] Minimum multiword DMA transfer cycle time per word : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 66] Recommended multiword DMA transfer cycle time : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 67] Minimum PIO transfer cycle time without flow control : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 68] Minimum PIO transfer cycle time with IORDY flow control : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 75] Maximum queue depth : 0
[Word 80] Major version number : Supports ATA/ATAPI-7
[Word 81] Minor version number : Device does not report version
[Word 82-84] Command set supported :
NOP command supported : Yes
READ BUFFER command supported : Yes
WRITE BUFFER command supported : Yes
Host Protected Area feature set supported : No
DEVICE RESET command supported : No
SERVICE interrupt supported : No
Release interrupt supported : No
Look-ahead supported : No
Write cache supported : Yes
PACKET Command feature set supported : No
Power Management feature set supported : Yes
Removable Media feature set supported : No
Security Mode feature set supported : Yes
SMART feature set supported : Yes
SET MAX security extension supported : No
SET FEATURES subcommand required to spinup after power-up : No
Power-Up In Standby feature set supported : No
Removable Media Status Notification feature set supported : No
Advanced Power Management feature set supported : Yes
CFA feature set supported : Yes
READ/WRITE DMA QUEUED supported : No
DOWNLOAD MICROCODE command supported : No
[Word 85-87] Command set/feature enabled :
NOP command enabled : No
READ BUFFER command enabled : No
WRITE BUFFER command enabled : No
Host Protected Area feature set enabled : No
DEVICE RESET command enabled : No
SERVICE interrupt enabled : No
Release interrupt enabled : No
Look-ahead enabled : No
Write cache enabled : No
PACKET Command feature set enabled : No
Power Management feature set enabled : No
Removable Media feature set enabled : No
Security Mode feature set enabled : No
SMART feature set enabled : No
SET MAX security extension enabled : No
Power-Up In Standby feature set enabled : No
Removable Media Status Notification feature set enabled : No
Advanced Power Management feature set enabled : No
CFA feature set enabled : Yes
[Word 88] Ultra DMA mode active : None
[Word 88] Ultra DMA mode supported : 4 (66.7 MB/s)
[Word 89] Time required for Security erase unit completion : 2 minutes
[Word 90] Time required for Enhanced security erase completion : Value not specified
[Word 91] Advanced power management level value : 0
[Word 92] Master Password Revison Code : FFFE
[Word 127] Removable Media Status Notification feature set support : No
[Word 128] Security status :
Security level : High
Enhanced security erase supported : No
Security count expired : No
Security frozen : No
Security locked : No
Security enabled : No
Security supported : Yes
[Word 160] CFA Power Mode 1 :
CFA power mode 1 is required for one or more commands : No
CFA power mode 1 disbled : No
Maximum average RMS current required : 500 Milliamperes




Avec DS32 on peut s'apercevoir que le débit de la carte reste stable, c'est très linéaire, stockage Flash oblige.




ATTO et Roadkil indiquent un débit maximum de 14-15Mo/s, ce qui parait normal compte tenu du mode de transfert en Word DMA mode 2 qui est de 16.6Mo/s en théorique.

Carte CF Cisco



Voyons maintenant si la carte "Cisco" peut mieux faire...

IDEdrive 2.0 :

SECONDARY MASTER :
List output by standard : ATA-5
[Word 0] General configuration :
Type of device : ATA
Removable media device : No
Not removable controller and/or device : Yes
[Word 1] Number of logical cylinders : 4064
[Word 3] Number of logical heads : 16
[Word 6] Number of logical sectors per logical track : 63
[Word 10-19] Serial number : UNIGEN3 30001046
[Word 21] Cache size : 1 KB
[Word 23-26] Firmware revision : FW100511
[Word 27-46] Model number : UNIGEN FLASH
[Word 47] Maximum number of sectors per interrupt : 2
[Word 49] Capabilities :
Stanby timer values supported : No
IORDY supported : Yes
IORDY may be disabled : Yes
[Word 54] Number of current logical cylinders : 4064
[Word 55] Number of current logical heads : 16
[Word 56] Number of current logical sectors per track : 63
[Word 57-58] Current capacity in sectors : 4096512
[Word 59] Current number of sectors per interrupt : 2
[Word 59] Multiple sector setting is valid : Yes
[Word 60-61] Total number of user addressable sectors (LBA mode) : 4096512 (2.097 GB)
[Word 63] Multiword DMA transfer mode active : None
[Word 63] Multiword DMA transfer mode supported : 2 (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 64] Advanced PIO transfer mode supported : 4 (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 65] Minimum multiword DMA transfer cycle time per word : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 66] Recommended multiword DMA transfer cycle time : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 67] Minimum PIO transfer cycle time without flow control : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 68] Minimum PIO transfer cycle time with IORDY flow control : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 75] Maximum queue depth : 0
[Word 80] Major version number : Supports ATA/ATAPI-5
[Word 81] Minor version number : Device does not report version
[Word 82-84] Command set supported :
NOP command supported : Yes
READ BUFFER command supported : Yes
WRITE BUFFER command supported : Yes
Host Protected Area feature set supported : Yes
DEVICE RESET command supported : No
SERVICE interrupt supported : No
Release interrupt supported : No
Look-ahead supported : No
Write cache supported : No
PACKET Command feature set supported : No
Power Management feature set supported : Yes
Removable Media feature set supported : No
Security Mode feature set supported : No
SMART feature set supported : Yes
SET MAX security extension supported : No
SET FEATURES subcommand required to spinup after power-up : No
Power-Up In Standby feature set supported : No
Removable Media Status Notification feature set supported : No
Advanced Power Management feature set supported : No
CFA feature set supported : Yes
READ/WRITE DMA QUEUED supported : No
DOWNLOAD MICROCODE command supported : No
[Word 85-87] Command set/feature enabled :
NOP command enabled : Yes
READ BUFFER command enabled : Yes
WRITE BUFFER command enabled : Yes
Host Protected Area feature set enabled : Yes
DEVICE RESET command enabled : No
SERVICE interrupt enabled : No
Release interrupt enabled : No
Look-ahead enabled : No
Write cache enabled : No
PACKET Command feature set enabled : No
Power Management feature set enabled : Yes
Removable Media feature set enabled : No
Security Mode feature set enabled : No
SMART feature set enabled : Yes
SET MAX security extension enabled : No
Power-Up In Standby feature set enabled : No
Removable Media Status Notification feature set enabled : No
Advanced Power Management feature set enabled : No
CFA feature set enabled : Yes
[Word 88] Ultra DMA mode active : None
[Word 88] Ultra DMA mode supported : 4 (66.7 MB/s)
[Word 89] Time required for Security erase unit completion : Value not specified
[Word 90] Time required for Enhanced security erase completion : Value not specified
[Word 91] Advanced power management level value : 0
[Word 92] Master Password Revison Code : 00
[Word 127] Removable Media Status Notification feature set support : No
[Word 128] Security status :
Security level : High
Enhanced security erase supported : No
Security count expired : No
Security frozen : No
Security locked : No
Security enabled : No
Security supported : No
[Word 160] CFA Power Mode 1 :
CFA power mode 1 is required for one or more commands : Yes
CFA power mode 1 disbled : No
Maximum average RMS current required : 100 Milliamperes






Idem débits très stables mais elle fait nettement mieux que la Transcend vu précédemment surtout sur les petites écritures sur les fichiers (ATTO et Roadkil). Cette carte est donc à privilégier. :)

DOM Kingspec Industrial 4Go



IDEdrive 2.0 :

SECONDARY MASTER :
List output by standard : ATA-5
[Word 0] General configuration :
Type of device : ATA
Removable media device : No
Not removable controller and/or device : Yes
[Word 1] Number of logical cylinders : 7671
[Word 3] Number of logical heads : 16
[Word 6] Number of logical sectors per logical track : 63
[Word 10-19] Serial number : 987021600172
[Word 21] Cache size : 1 KB
[Word 23-26] Firmware revision : 20131216
[Word 27-46] Model number : 40VS2-004S
[Word 47] Maximum number of sectors per interrupt : 1
[Word 49] Capabilities :
Stanby timer values supported : No
IORDY supported : Yes
IORDY may be disabled : Yes
[Word 54] Number of current logical cylinders : 7671
[Word 55] Number of current logical heads : 16
[Word 56] Number of current logical sectors per track : 63
[Word 57-58] Current capacity in sectors : 7732368
[Word 59] Current number of sectors per interrupt : 0
[Word 59] Multiple sector setting is valid : Yes
[Word 60-61] Total number of user addressable sectors (LBA mode) : 7732368 (3.959 GB)
[Word 63] Multiword DMA transfer mode active : 2 (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 63] Multiword DMA transfer mode supported : 2 (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 64] Advanced PIO transfer mode supported : 4 (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 65] Minimum multiword DMA transfer cycle time per word : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 66] Recommended multiword DMA transfer cycle time : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 67] Minimum PIO transfer cycle time without flow control : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 68] Minimum PIO transfer cycle time with IORDY flow control : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 75] Maximum queue depth : 0
[Word 80] Major version number : Supports ATA/ATAPI-9
[Word 81] Minor version number : Device does not report version
[Word 82-84] Command set supported :
NOP command supported : Yes
READ BUFFER command supported : Yes
WRITE BUFFER command supported : Yes
Host Protected Area feature set supported : No
DEVICE RESET command supported : No
SERVICE interrupt supported : No
Release interrupt supported : No
Look-ahead supported : No
Write cache supported : Yes
PACKET Command feature set supported : No
Power Management feature set supported : Yes
Removable Media feature set supported : No
Security Mode feature set supported : No
SMART feature set supported : Yes
SET MAX security extension supported : No
SET FEATURES subcommand required to spinup after power-up : No
Power-Up In Standby feature set supported : No
Removable Media Status Notification feature set supported : No
Advanced Power Management feature set supported : No
CFA feature set supported : No
READ/WRITE DMA QUEUED supported : No
DOWNLOAD MICROCODE command supported : No
[Word 85-87] Command set/feature enabled :
NOP command enabled : Yes
READ BUFFER command enabled : Yes
WRITE BUFFER command enabled : Yes
Host Protected Area feature set enabled : No
DEVICE RESET command enabled : No
SERVICE interrupt enabled : No
Release interrupt enabled : No
Look-ahead enabled : No
Write cache enabled : No
PACKET Command feature set enabled : No
Power Management feature set enabled : Yes
Removable Media feature set enabled : No
Security Mode feature set enabled : No
SMART feature set enabled : Yes
SET MAX security extension enabled : No
Power-Up In Standby feature set enabled : No
Removable Media Status Notification feature set enabled : No
Advanced Power Management feature set enabled : No
CFA feature set enabled : No
[Word 88] Ultra DMA mode active : None
[Word 88] Ultra DMA mode supported : 6 (133.3 MB/s)
[Word 89] Time required for Security erase unit completion : Value not specified
[Word 90] Time required for Enhanced security erase completion : Value not specified
[Word 91] Advanced power management level value : 0
[Word 92] Master Password Revison Code : 00
[Word 127] Removable Media Status Notification feature set support : No
[Word 128] Security status :
Security level : High
Enhanced security erase supported : No
Security count expired : No
Security frozen : No
Security locked : No
Security enabled : No
Security supported : No




RAS avec DS32, même comportement qu'avec les cartes CF.




Résultats que je qualifierais de vraiment bizarres. Selon la taille des blocs le DOM ne réagit pas de la même manière et ce sur 2 logiciels différents.

Carte SD Samsung 16Go EVO



IDEdrive 2.0 :

SECONDARY MASTER :
List output by standard : ATA-5
[Word 0] General configuration :
Type of device : ATA
Removable media device : No
Not removable controller and/or device : Yes
[Word 1] Number of logical cylinders : 16383
[Word 3] Number of logical heads : 16
[Word 6] Number of logical sectors per logical track : 63
[Word 10-19] Serial number : CD1E0471
[Word 21] Cache size : 8 KB
[Word 23-26] Firmware revision : Rev 1.2
[Word 27-46] Model number : SINTECHI HighSpeed SD to CF Adapter V1.0
[Word 47] Maximum number of sectors per interrupt : 1
[Word 49] Capabilities :
Stanby timer values supported : No
IORDY supported : Yes
IORDY may be disabled : Yes
[Word 54] Number of current logical cylinders : 16383
[Word 55] Number of current logical heads : 16
[Word 56] Number of current logical sectors per track : 63
[Word 57-58] Current capacity in sectors : 31291392
[Word 59] Current number of sectors per interrupt : 1
[Word 59] Multiple sector setting is valid : Yes
[Word 60-61] Total number of user addressable sectors (LBA mode) : 31291392 (16.021 GB)
[Word 63] Multiword DMA transfer mode active : 0 (4.2 MB/s)
[Word 63] Multiword DMA transfer mode supported : 2 (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 64] Advanced PIO transfer mode supported : 4 (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 65] Minimum multiword DMA transfer cycle time per word : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 66] Recommended multiword DMA transfer cycle time : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 67] Minimum PIO transfer cycle time without flow control : 240 ns (8.3 MB/s)
[Word 68] Minimum PIO transfer cycle time with IORDY flow control : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 75] Maximum queue depth : 0
[Word 80] Major version number : Supports ATA/ATAPI-7
[Word 81] Minor version number : 1536
[Word 82-84] Command set supported :
NOP command supported : No
READ BUFFER command supported : No
WRITE BUFFER command supported : No
Host Protected Area feature set supported : No
DEVICE RESET command supported : No
SERVICE interrupt supported : No
Release interrupt supported : No
Look-ahead supported : No
Write cache supported : No
PACKET Command feature set supported : No
Power Management feature set supported : No
Removable Media feature set supported : No
Security Mode feature set supported : No
SMART feature set supported : Yes
SET MAX security extension supported : No
SET FEATURES subcommand required to spinup after power-up : No
Power-Up In Standby feature set supported : No
Removable Media Status Notification feature set supported : No
Advanced Power Management feature set supported : No
CFA feature set supported : Yes
READ/WRITE DMA QUEUED supported : No
DOWNLOAD MICROCODE command supported : No
[Word 85-87] Command set/feature enabled :
NOP command enabled : No
READ BUFFER command enabled : No
WRITE BUFFER command enabled : No
Host Protected Area feature set enabled : No
DEVICE RESET command enabled : No
SERVICE interrupt enabled : No
Release interrupt enabled : No
Look-ahead enabled : No
Write cache enabled : No
PACKET Command feature set enabled : No
Power Management feature set enabled : No
Removable Media feature set enabled : No
Security Mode feature set enabled : No
SMART feature set enabled : No
SET MAX security extension enabled : No
Power-Up In Standby feature set enabled : No
Removable Media Status Notification feature set enabled : No
Advanced Power Management feature set enabled : No
CFA feature set enabled : Yes
[Word 88] Ultra DMA mode active : None
[Word 88] Ultra DMA mode supported : 5 (100.0 MB/s)
[Word 89] Time required for Security erase unit completion : Value not specified
[Word 90] Time required for Enhanced security erase completion : Value not specified
[Word 91] Advanced power management level value : 0
[Word 92] Master Password Revison Code : 00
[Word 127] Removable Media Status Notification feature set support : No
[Word 128] Security status :
Security level : High
Enhanced security erase supported : No
Security count expired : No
Security frozen : No
Security locked : No
Security enabled : No
Security supported : No




DS32 montre un gros rectangle bleu à défaut d'une ligne plate. En réalité c'est parce que les débits ne sont pas du tout stables, et jouent au yoyo. Le graphe est en dents de scie tassé. Admirez les valeurs dans la zone de gauche : le débit va de 67Ko/s à 8.4Mo/s : autrement dit c'est le grand écart !



ATTO qui ici est configuré en mode "Direct I/O" (accès physique direct) donne des valeurs très correctes, les cartes CF et le DOM sont laissés sur place.



Ici par contre ce n'est pas la même chanson, c'est très instable et très en deçà des cartes CF. J'ai l'impression que dès qu'on fait appel à l'aspect logique ça s'écroule. Problème de firmware ?

Carte SD Transcend 64Go





Même chose qu'avec la carte SD Samsung de 16Go, le grand écart est toujours là même si le graphe à l'air moins vilain. On a l'impression que le chip Sintechi arrive à mieux gérer cette carte.



ATTO se comporte de la même manière qu'avec la Samsung 16Go. Il est à noter que le bench a du être relancé en raison d'une erreur la première fois :





C'est le jour et la nuit avec la Samsung 16Go. Résultats moins linéaires qu'avec une CF ou le DOM mais ça passe. On divise le temps d'accès par 50.

Bilan pour le PC Pentium


Le DOM et les cartes SD font ressortir des bizarreries aléatoires. Seules les CF sont dans les clous de manière constante. La carte Cisco offre la meilleure option stabilité/rapidité.

PC de test n°2 - Génération Pentium II



Description



  • PC Assemblé
  • Carte mère Gigabyte GA-6BXC
  • Intel Pentium II 400Mhz
  • 128Mo de RAM
  • Chipset : Intel 440BX / PIIX4
  • Nappe IDE : 40 fils
  • Windows 2000 SP4
  • Configuration BIOS : IDE tout en automatique (PIO, DMA, etc...)
  • Configuration Windows : Mode DMA activé


Carte CF Transcend



IDEdrive 2.0 :

SECONDARY MASTER :
List output by standard : ATA-5
[Word 0] General configuration :
Type of device : Not specified
Removable media device : Yes
Not removable controller and/or device : No
[Word 1] Number of logical cylinders : 7769
[Word 3] Number of logical heads : 16
[Word 6] Number of logical sectors per logical track : 63
[Word 10-19] Serial number : A67801C009220F000447
[Word 21] Cache size : 1 KB
[Word 23-26] Firmware revision : 20110407
[Word 27-46] Model number : TS4GCF133
[Word 47] Maximum number of sectors per interrupt : 1
[Word 49] Capabilities :
Stanby timer values supported : No
IORDY supported : Yes
IORDY may be disabled : Yes
[Word 54] Number of current logical cylinders : 7769
[Word 55] Number of current logical heads : 16
[Word 56] Number of current logical sectors per track : 63
[Word 57-58] Current capacity in sectors : 7831152
[Word 59] Current number of sectors per interrupt : 1
[Word 59] Multiple sector setting is valid : Yes
[Word 60-61] Total number of user addressable sectors (LBA mode) : 7831152 (4.010 GB)
[Word 63] Multiword DMA transfer mode active : None
[Word 63] Multiword DMA transfer mode supported : 2 (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 64] Advanced PIO transfer mode supported : 4 (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 65] Minimum multiword DMA transfer cycle time per word : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 66] Recommended multiword DMA transfer cycle time : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 67] Minimum PIO transfer cycle time without flow control : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 68] Minimum PIO transfer cycle time with IORDY flow control : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 75] Maximum queue depth : 0
[Word 80] Major version number : Supports ATA/ATAPI-7
[Word 81] Minor version number : Device does not report version
[Word 82-84] Command set supported :
NOP command supported : Yes
READ BUFFER command supported : Yes
WRITE BUFFER command supported : Yes
Host Protected Area feature set supported : No
DEVICE RESET command supported : No
SERVICE interrupt supported : No
Release interrupt supported : No
Look-ahead supported : No
Write cache supported : Yes
PACKET Command feature set supported : No
Power Management feature set supported : Yes
Removable Media feature set supported : No
Security Mode feature set supported : Yes
SMART feature set supported : Yes
SET MAX security extension supported : No
SET FEATURES subcommand required to spinup after power-up : No
Power-Up In Standby feature set supported : No
Removable Media Status Notification feature set supported : No
Advanced Power Management feature set supported : Yes
CFA feature set supported : Yes
READ/WRITE DMA QUEUED supported : No
DOWNLOAD MICROCODE command supported : No
[Word 85-87] Command set/feature enabled :
NOP command enabled : No
READ BUFFER command enabled : No
WRITE BUFFER command enabled : No
Host Protected Area feature set enabled : No
DEVICE RESET command enabled : No
SERVICE interrupt enabled : No
Release interrupt enabled : No
Look-ahead enabled : No
Write cache enabled : Yes
PACKET Command feature set enabled : No
Power Management feature set enabled : No
Removable Media feature set enabled : No
Security Mode feature set enabled : No
SMART feature set enabled : Yes
SET MAX security extension enabled : No
Power-Up In Standby feature set enabled : No
Removable Media Status Notification feature set enabled : No
Advanced Power Management feature set enabled : No
CFA feature set enabled : Yes
[Word 88] Ultra DMA mode active : 2 (33.3 MB/s)
[Word 88] Ultra DMA mode supported : 4 (66.7 MB/s)
[Word 89] Time required for Security erase unit completion : 2 minutes
[Word 90] Time required for Enhanced security erase completion : Value not specified
[Word 91] Advanced power management level value : 0
[Word 92] Master Password Revison Code : FFFE
[Word 127] Removable Media Status Notification feature set support : No
[Word 128] Security status :
Security level : High
Enhanced security erase supported : No
Security count expired : No
Security frozen : No
Security locked : No
Security enabled : No
Security supported : Yes
[Word 160] CFA Power Mode 1 :
CFA power mode 1 is required for one or more commands : No
CFA power mode 1 disbled : No
Maximum average RMS current required : 500 Milliamperes







Par rapport au PC Pentium 1 les débits en lecture montent beaucoup et passent de 7-8Mo/s à 23/24Mo/s. RAS sur le reste.

Carte CF Cisco



IDEdrive 2.0 :

SECONDARY MASTER :
List output by standard : ATA-5
[Word 0] General configuration :
Type of device : ATA
Removable media device : No
Not removable controller and/or device : Yes
[Word 1] Number of logical cylinders : 4064
[Word 3] Number of logical heads : 16
[Word 6] Number of logical sectors per logical track : 63
[Word 10-19] Serial number : UNIGEN3 30001046
[Word 21] Cache size : 1 KB
[Word 23-26] Firmware revision : FW100511
[Word 27-46] Model number : UNIGEN FLASH
[Word 47] Maximum number of sectors per interrupt : 2
[Word 49] Capabilities :
Stanby timer values supported : No
IORDY supported : Yes
IORDY may be disabled : Yes
[Word 54] Number of current logical cylinders : 4064
[Word 55] Number of current logical heads : 16
[Word 56] Number of current logical sectors per track : 63
[Word 57-58] Current capacity in sectors : 4096512
[Word 59] Current number of sectors per interrupt : 2
[Word 59] Multiple sector setting is valid : Yes
[Word 60-61] Total number of user addressable sectors (LBA mode) : 4096512 (2.097 GB)
[Word 63] Multiword DMA transfer mode active : None
[Word 63] Multiword DMA transfer mode supported : 2 (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 64] Advanced PIO transfer mode supported : 4 (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 65] Minimum multiword DMA transfer cycle time per word : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 66] Recommended multiword DMA transfer cycle time : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 67] Minimum PIO transfer cycle time without flow control : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 68] Minimum PIO transfer cycle time with IORDY flow control : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 75] Maximum queue depth : 0
[Word 80] Major version number : Supports ATA/ATAPI-5
[Word 81] Minor version number : Device does not report version
[Word 82-84] Command set supported :
NOP command supported : Yes
READ BUFFER command supported : Yes
WRITE BUFFER command supported : Yes
Host Protected Area feature set supported : Yes
DEVICE RESET command supported : No
SERVICE interrupt supported : No
Release interrupt supported : No
Look-ahead supported : No
Write cache supported : No
PACKET Command feature set supported : No
Power Management feature set supported : Yes
Removable Media feature set supported : No
Security Mode feature set supported : No
SMART feature set supported : Yes
SET MAX security extension supported : No
SET FEATURES subcommand required to spinup after power-up : No
Power-Up In Standby feature set supported : No
Removable Media Status Notification feature set supported : No
Advanced Power Management feature set supported : No
CFA feature set supported : Yes
READ/WRITE DMA QUEUED supported : No
DOWNLOAD MICROCODE command supported : No
[Word 85-87] Command set/feature enabled :
NOP command enabled : Yes
READ BUFFER command enabled : Yes
WRITE BUFFER command enabled : Yes
Host Protected Area feature set enabled : Yes
DEVICE RESET command enabled : No
SERVICE interrupt enabled : No
Release interrupt enabled : No
Look-ahead enabled : No
Write cache enabled : No
PACKET Command feature set enabled : No
Power Management feature set enabled : Yes
Removable Media feature set enabled : No
Security Mode feature set enabled : No
SMART feature set enabled : Yes
SET MAX security extension enabled : No
Power-Up In Standby feature set enabled : No
Removable Media Status Notification feature set enabled : No
Advanced Power Management feature set enabled : No
CFA feature set enabled : Yes
[Word 88] Ultra DMA mode active : 2 (33.3 MB/s)
[Word 88] Ultra DMA mode supported : 4 (66.7 MB/s)
[Word 89] Time required for Security erase unit completion : Value not specified
[Word 90] Time required for Enhanced security erase completion : Value not specified
[Word 91] Advanced power management level value : 0
[Word 92] Master Password Revison Code : 00
[Word 127] Removable Media Status Notification feature set support : No
[Word 128] Security status :
Security level : High
Enhanced security erase supported : No
Security count expired : No
Security frozen : No
Security locked : No
Security enabled : No
Security supported : No
[Word 160] CFA Power Mode 1 :
CFA power mode 1 is required for one or more commands : Yes
CFA power mode 1 disbled : No
Maximum average RMS current required : 100 Milliamperes







Placée sur un meilleur southbridge, la Transcend n'a plus rien a envier à la Cisco qui s'avère autant rapide. Cette dernière reste toutefois toujours meilleure en écriture.

DOM Kingspec Industrial 4Go



IDEdrive 2.0 :

SECONDARY MASTER :
List output by standard : ATA-5
[Word 0] General configuration :
Type of device : ATA
Removable media device : No
Not removable controller and/or device : Yes
[Word 1] Number of logical cylinders : 7671
[Word 3] Number of logical heads : 16
[Word 6] Number of logical sectors per logical track : 63
[Word 10-19] Serial number : 987021600172
[Word 21] Cache size : 1 KB
[Word 23-26] Firmware revision : 20131216
[Word 27-46] Model number : 40VS2-004S
[Word 47] Maximum number of sectors per interrupt : 1
[Word 49] Capabilities :
Stanby timer values supported : No
IORDY supported : Yes
IORDY may be disabled : Yes
[Word 54] Number of current logical cylinders : 7671
[Word 55] Number of current logical heads : 16
[Word 56] Number of current logical sectors per track : 63
[Word 57-58] Current capacity in sectors : 7732368
[Word 59] Current number of sectors per interrupt : 1
[Word 59] Multiple sector setting is valid : Yes
[Word 60-61] Total number of user addressable sectors (LBA mode) : 7732368 (3.959 GB)
[Word 63] Multiword DMA transfer mode active : None
[Word 63] Multiword DMA transfer mode supported : 2 (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 64] Advanced PIO transfer mode supported : 4 (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 65] Minimum multiword DMA transfer cycle time per word : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 66] Recommended multiword DMA transfer cycle time : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 67] Minimum PIO transfer cycle time without flow control : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 68] Minimum PIO transfer cycle time with IORDY flow control : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 75] Maximum queue depth : 0
[Word 80] Major version number : Supports ATA/ATAPI-9
[Word 81] Minor version number : Device does not report version
[Word 82-84] Command set supported :
NOP command supported : Yes
READ BUFFER command supported : Yes
WRITE BUFFER command supported : Yes
Host Protected Area feature set supported : No
DEVICE RESET command supported : No
SERVICE interrupt supported : No
Release interrupt supported : No
Look-ahead supported : No
Write cache supported : Yes
PACKET Command feature set supported : No
Power Management feature set supported : Yes
Removable Media feature set supported : No
Security Mode feature set supported : No
SMART feature set supported : Yes
SET MAX security extension supported : No
SET FEATURES subcommand required to spinup after power-up : No
Power-Up In Standby feature set supported : No
Removable Media Status Notification feature set supported : No
Advanced Power Management feature set supported : No
CFA feature set supported : No
READ/WRITE DMA QUEUED supported : No
DOWNLOAD MICROCODE command supported : No
[Word 85-87] Command set/feature enabled :
NOP command enabled : Yes
READ BUFFER command enabled : Yes
WRITE BUFFER command enabled : Yes
Host Protected Area feature set enabled : No
DEVICE RESET command enabled : No
SERVICE interrupt enabled : No
Release interrupt enabled : No
Look-ahead enabled : No
Write cache enabled : Yes
PACKET Command feature set enabled : No
Power Management feature set enabled : Yes
Removable Media feature set enabled : No
Security Mode feature set enabled : No
SMART feature set enabled : Yes
SET MAX security extension enabled : No
Power-Up In Standby feature set enabled : No
Removable Media Status Notification feature set enabled : No
Advanced Power Management feature set enabled : No
CFA feature set enabled : No
[Word 88] Ultra DMA mode active : 2 (33.3 MB/s)
[Word 88] Ultra DMA mode supported : 6 (133.3 MB/s)
[Word 89] Time required for Security erase unit completion : Value not specified
[Word 90] Time required for Enhanced security erase completion : Value not specified
[Word 91] Advanced power management level value : 0
[Word 92] Master Password Revison Code : 00
[Word 127] Removable Media Status Notification feature set support : No
[Word 128] Security status :
Security level : High
Enhanced security erase supported : No
Security count expired : No
Security frozen : No
Security locked : No
Security enabled : No
Security supported : No




Le DOM affiche ici des débits supérieurs aux deux cartes CF.



Là encore les débits sont nettement meilleurs que les deux cartes CF.




On grimpe ici à 29-30Mo/s, c'est à dire à la limite de l'Ultra-DMA 33 que ce DOM à l'air de bien apprécier. ;)

Carte SD Samsung 16Go EVO



IDEdrive 2.0 :

SECONDARY MASTER :
List output by standard : ATA-5
[Word 0] General configuration :
Type of device : ATA
Removable media device : No
Not removable controller and/or device : Yes
[Word 1] Number of logical cylinders : 16383
[Word 3] Number of logical heads : 16
[Word 6] Number of logical sectors per logical track : 63
[Word 10-19] Serial number : CD1E0471
[Word 21] Cache size : 8 KB
[Word 23-26] Firmware revision : Rev 1.2
[Word 27-46] Model number : SINTECHI HighSpeed SD to CF Adapter V1.0
[Word 47] Maximum number of sectors per interrupt : 1
[Word 49] Capabilities :
Stanby timer values supported : No
IORDY supported : Yes
IORDY may be disabled : Yes
[Word 54] Number of current logical cylinders : 16383
[Word 55] Number of current logical heads : 16
[Word 56] Number of current logical sectors per track : 63
[Word 57-58] Current capacity in sectors : 31291392
[Word 59] Current number of sectors per interrupt : 1
[Word 59] Multiple sector setting is valid : Yes
[Word 60-61] Total number of user addressable sectors (LBA mode) : 31291392 (16.021 GB)
[Word 63] Multiword DMA transfer mode active : None
[Word 63] Multiword DMA transfer mode supported : 2 (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 64] Advanced PIO transfer mode supported : 4 (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 65] Minimum multiword DMA transfer cycle time per word : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 66] Recommended multiword DMA transfer cycle time : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 67] Minimum PIO transfer cycle time without flow control : 240 ns (8.3 MB/s)
[Word 68] Minimum PIO transfer cycle time with IORDY flow control : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 75] Maximum queue depth : 0
[Word 80] Major version number : Supports ATA/ATAPI-7
[Word 81] Minor version number : 1536
[Word 82-84] Command set supported :
NOP command supported : No
READ BUFFER command supported : No
WRITE BUFFER command supported : No
Host Protected Area feature set supported : No
DEVICE RESET command supported : No
SERVICE interrupt supported : No
Release interrupt supported : No
Look-ahead supported : No
Write cache supported : No
PACKET Command feature set supported : No
Power Management feature set supported : No
Removable Media feature set supported : No
Security Mode feature set supported : No
SMART feature set supported : Yes
SET MAX security extension supported : No
SET FEATURES subcommand required to spinup after power-up : No
Power-Up In Standby feature set supported : No
Removable Media Status Notification feature set supported : No
Advanced Power Management feature set supported : No
CFA feature set supported : Yes
READ/WRITE DMA QUEUED supported : No
DOWNLOAD MICROCODE command supported : No
[Word 85-87] Command set/feature enabled :
NOP command enabled : No
READ BUFFER command enabled : No
WRITE BUFFER command enabled : No
Host Protected Area feature set enabled : No
DEVICE RESET command enabled : No
SERVICE interrupt enabled : No
Release interrupt enabled : No
Look-ahead enabled : No
Write cache enabled : No
PACKET Command feature set enabled : No
Power Management feature set enabled : No
Removable Media feature set enabled : No
Security Mode feature set enabled : No
SMART feature set enabled : Yes
SET MAX security extension enabled : No
Power-Up In Standby feature set enabled : No
Removable Media Status Notification feature set enabled : No
Advanced Power Management feature set enabled : No
CFA feature set enabled : Yes
[Word 88] Ultra DMA mode active : 2 (33.3 MB/s)
[Word 88] Ultra DMA mode supported : 5 (100.0 MB/s)
[Word 89] Time required for Security erase unit completion : Value not specified
[Word 90] Time required for Enhanced security erase completion : Value not specified
[Word 91] Advanced power management level value : 0
[Word 92] Master Password Revison Code : 00
[Word 127] Removable Media Status Notification feature set support : No
[Word 128] Security status :
Security level : High
Enhanced security erase supported : No
Security count expired : No
Security frozen : No
Security locked : No
Security enabled : No
Security supported : No




Là encore ce n'est pas brillant, du yoyo, entre 2 et 23Mo/s.



ATTO donne des résultats très satisfaisants.



Résultats pas stables. Temps d'accès très long de 43ms.




Le test en accès physique direct n'a pu aller au bout. :lol
Le module Sintechi n'a pû être détecté au BIOS après un RESET au bouton, visiblement planté, une coupure électrique a été nécessaire. Fail total.

Carte SD Transcend 64Go



Impossible de faire le test, le BIOS plante à la reconnaissance du module Sintechi au POST en raison de la carte de 64Go qui est surement trop grosse pour un BIOS Award 4.51 de 1998. Le BIOS du Zenith (AMIBIOS) devait laisser pisser de son coté en laissant la main à l'OS.

PC de test n°3 - Génération Pentium 4



Description



  • PC Compaq Evo D510 SFF
  • Intel Pentium 4 2.4Ghz Northwood
  • 1Go de RAM
  • Chipset : Intel 845G / ICH4 - 82801DB
  • Nappe IDE : 80 fils
  • Windows XP Service Pack 2
  • Configuration BIOS : IDE tout en automatique (PIO, DMA, etc...)
  • Configuration Windows : Mode DMA activé


Carte CF Transcend



IDEdrive 2.0 :

SECONDARY MASTER :
List output by standard : ATA-5
[Word 0] General configuration :
Type of device : Not specified
Removable media device : Yes
Not removable controller and/or device : No
[Word 1] Number of logical cylinders : 7769
[Word 3] Number of logical heads : 16
[Word 6] Number of logical sectors per logical track : 63
[Word 10-19] Serial number : A67801C009220F000447
[Word 21] Cache size : 1 KB
[Word 23-26] Firmware revision : 20110407
[Word 27-46] Model number : TS4GCF133
[Word 47] Maximum number of sectors per interrupt : 1
[Word 49] Capabilities :
Stanby timer values supported : No
IORDY supported : Yes
IORDY may be disabled : Yes
[Word 54] Number of current logical cylinders : 7769
[Word 55] Number of current logical heads : 16
[Word 56] Number of current logical sectors per track : 63
[Word 57-58] Current capacity in sectors : 7831152
[Word 59] Current number of sectors per interrupt : 1
[Word 59] Multiple sector setting is valid : Yes
[Word 60-61] Total number of user addressable sectors (LBA mode) : 7831152 (4.010 GB)
[Word 63] Multiword DMA transfer mode active : None
[Word 63] Multiword DMA transfer mode supported : 2 (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 64] Advanced PIO transfer mode supported : 4 (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 65] Minimum multiword DMA transfer cycle time per word : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 66] Recommended multiword DMA transfer cycle time : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 67] Minimum PIO transfer cycle time without flow control : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 68] Minimum PIO transfer cycle time with IORDY flow control : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 75] Maximum queue depth : 0
[Word 80] Major version number : Supports ATA/ATAPI-7
[Word 81] Minor version number : Device does not report version
[Word 82-84] Command set supported :
NOP command supported : Yes
READ BUFFER command supported : Yes
WRITE BUFFER command supported : Yes
Host Protected Area feature set supported : No
DEVICE RESET command supported : No
SERVICE interrupt supported : No
Release interrupt supported : No
Look-ahead supported : No
Write cache supported : Yes
PACKET Command feature set supported : No
Power Management feature set supported : Yes
Removable Media feature set supported : No
Security Mode feature set supported : Yes
SMART feature set supported : Yes
SET MAX security extension supported : No
SET FEATURES subcommand required to spinup after power-up : No
Power-Up In Standby feature set supported : No
Removable Media Status Notification feature set supported : No
Advanced Power Management feature set supported : Yes
CFA feature set supported : Yes
READ/WRITE DMA QUEUED supported : No
DOWNLOAD MICROCODE command supported : No
[Word 85-87] Command set/feature enabled :
NOP command enabled : No
READ BUFFER command enabled : No
WRITE BUFFER command enabled : No
Host Protected Area feature set enabled : No
DEVICE RESET command enabled : No
SERVICE interrupt enabled : No
Release interrupt enabled : No
Look-ahead enabled : No
Write cache enabled : Yes
PACKET Command feature set enabled : No
Power Management feature set enabled : No
Removable Media feature set enabled : No
Security Mode feature set enabled : No
SMART feature set enabled : Yes
SET MAX security extension enabled : No
Power-Up In Standby feature set enabled : No
Removable Media Status Notification feature set enabled : No
Advanced Power Management feature set enabled : No
CFA feature set enabled : Yes
[Word 88] Ultra DMA mode active : 4 (66.7 MB/s)
[Word 88] Ultra DMA mode supported : 4 (66.7 MB/s)
[Word 89] Time required for Security erase unit completion : 2 minutes
[Word 90] Time required for Enhanced security erase completion : Value not specified
[Word 91] Advanced power management level value : 0
[Word 92] Master Password Revison Code : FFFE
[Word 127] Removable Media Status Notification feature set support : No
[Word 128] Security status :
Security level : High
Enhanced security erase supported : No
Security count expired : No
Security frozen : Yes
Security locked : No
Security enabled : No
Security supported : Yes
[Word 160] CFA Power Mode 1 :
CFA power mode 1 is required for one or more commands : No
CFA power mode 1 disbled : No
Maximum average RMS current required : 500 Milliamperes







On arrive ici aux limites de la carte. Même en ATA-100 sur un ICH4 les débits n'augmentent plus.

Carte CF Cisco



IDEdrive 2.0 :

SECONDARY MASTER :
List output by standard : ATA-5
[Word 0] General configuration :
Type of device : ATA
Removable media device : No
Not removable controller and/or device : Yes
[Word 1] Number of logical cylinders : 4064
[Word 3] Number of logical heads : 16
[Word 6] Number of logical sectors per logical track : 63
[Word 10-19] Serial number : UNIGEN3 30001046
[Word 21] Cache size : 1 KB
[Word 23-26] Firmware revision : FW100511
[Word 27-46] Model number : UNIGEN FLASH
[Word 47] Maximum number of sectors per interrupt : 2
[Word 49] Capabilities :
Stanby timer values supported : No
IORDY supported : Yes
IORDY may be disabled : Yes
[Word 54] Number of current logical cylinders : 4064
[Word 55] Number of current logical heads : 16
[Word 56] Number of current logical sectors per track : 63
[Word 57-58] Current capacity in sectors : 4096512
[Word 59] Current number of sectors per interrupt : 2
[Word 59] Multiple sector setting is valid : Yes
[Word 60-61] Total number of user addressable sectors (LBA mode) : 4096512 (2.097 GB)
[Word 63] Multiword DMA transfer mode active : None
[Word 63] Multiword DMA transfer mode supported : 2 (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 64] Advanced PIO transfer mode supported : 4 (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 65] Minimum multiword DMA transfer cycle time per word : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 66] Recommended multiword DMA transfer cycle time : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 67] Minimum PIO transfer cycle time without flow control : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 68] Minimum PIO transfer cycle time with IORDY flow control : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 75] Maximum queue depth : 0
[Word 80] Major version number : Supports ATA/ATAPI-5
[Word 81] Minor version number : Device does not report version
[Word 82-84] Command set supported :
NOP command supported : Yes
READ BUFFER command supported : Yes
WRITE BUFFER command supported : Yes
Host Protected Area feature set supported : Yes
DEVICE RESET command supported : No
SERVICE interrupt supported : No
Release interrupt supported : No
Look-ahead supported : No
Write cache supported : No
PACKET Command feature set supported : No
Power Management feature set supported : Yes
Removable Media feature set supported : No
Security Mode feature set supported : No
SMART feature set supported : Yes
SET MAX security extension supported : No
SET FEATURES subcommand required to spinup after power-up : No
Power-Up In Standby feature set supported : No
Removable Media Status Notification feature set supported : No
Advanced Power Management feature set supported : No
CFA feature set supported : Yes
READ/WRITE DMA QUEUED supported : No
DOWNLOAD MICROCODE command supported : No
[Word 85-87] Command set/feature enabled :
NOP command enabled : Yes
READ BUFFER command enabled : Yes
WRITE BUFFER command enabled : Yes
Host Protected Area feature set enabled : Yes
DEVICE RESET command enabled : No
SERVICE interrupt enabled : No
Release interrupt enabled : No
Look-ahead enabled : No
Write cache enabled : No
PACKET Command feature set enabled : No
Power Management feature set enabled : Yes
Removable Media feature set enabled : No
Security Mode feature set enabled : No
SMART feature set enabled : Yes
SET MAX security extension enabled : No
Power-Up In Standby feature set enabled : No
Removable Media Status Notification feature set enabled : No
Advanced Power Management feature set enabled : No
CFA feature set enabled : Yes
[Word 88] Ultra DMA mode active : 4 (66.7 MB/s)
[Word 88] Ultra DMA mode supported : 4 (66.7 MB/s)
[Word 89] Time required for Security erase unit completion : Value not specified
[Word 90] Time required for Enhanced security erase completion : Value not specified
[Word 91] Advanced power management level value : 0
[Word 92] Master Password Revison Code : 00
[Word 127] Removable Media Status Notification feature set support : No
[Word 128] Security status :
Security level : High
Enhanced security erase supported : No
Security count expired : No
Security frozen : No
Security locked : No
Security enabled : No
Security supported : No
[Word 160] CFA Power Mode 1 :
CFA power mode 1 is required for one or more commands : Yes
CFA power mode 1 disbled : No
Maximum average RMS current required : 100 Milliamperes







Par contre la Cisco a encore de la ressource sous le pied, les débits augmentent par rapport au PIIX4 du Pentium II.

DOM Kingspec Industrial 4Go



IDEdrive 2.0 :

SECONDARY MASTER :
List output by standard : ATA-5
[Word 0] General configuration :
Type of device : ATA
Removable media device : No
Not removable controller and/or device : Yes
[Word 1] Number of logical cylinders : 7671
[Word 3] Number of logical heads : 16
[Word 6] Number of logical sectors per logical track : 63
[Word 10-19] Serial number : 987021600172
[Word 21] Cache size : 1 KB
[Word 23-26] Firmware revision : 20131216
[Word 27-46] Model number : 40VS2-004S
[Word 47] Maximum number of sectors per interrupt : 1
[Word 49] Capabilities :
Stanby timer values supported : No
IORDY supported : Yes
IORDY may be disabled : Yes
[Word 54] Number of current logical cylinders : 7671
[Word 55] Number of current logical heads : 16
[Word 56] Number of current logical sectors per track : 63
[Word 57-58] Current capacity in sectors : 7732368
[Word 59] Current number of sectors per interrupt : 1
[Word 59] Multiple sector setting is valid : Yes
[Word 60-61] Total number of user addressable sectors (LBA mode) : 7732368 (3.959 GB)
[Word 63] Multiword DMA transfer mode active : None
[Word 63] Multiword DMA transfer mode supported : 2 (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 64] Advanced PIO transfer mode supported : 4 (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 65] Minimum multiword DMA transfer cycle time per word : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 66] Recommended multiword DMA transfer cycle time : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 67] Minimum PIO transfer cycle time without flow control : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 68] Minimum PIO transfer cycle time with IORDY flow control : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 75] Maximum queue depth : 0
[Word 80] Major version number : Supports ATA/ATAPI-9
[Word 81] Minor version number : Device does not report version
[Word 82-84] Command set supported :
NOP command supported : Yes
READ BUFFER command supported : Yes
WRITE BUFFER command supported : Yes
Host Protected Area feature set supported : No
DEVICE RESET command supported : No
SERVICE interrupt supported : No
Release interrupt supported : No
Look-ahead supported : No
Write cache supported : Yes
PACKET Command feature set supported : No
Power Management feature set supported : Yes
Removable Media feature set supported : No
Security Mode feature set supported : No
SMART feature set supported : Yes
SET MAX security extension supported : No
SET FEATURES subcommand required to spinup after power-up : No
Power-Up In Standby feature set supported : No
Removable Media Status Notification feature set supported : No
Advanced Power Management feature set supported : No
CFA feature set supported : No
READ/WRITE DMA QUEUED supported : No
DOWNLOAD MICROCODE command supported : No
[Word 85-87] Command set/feature enabled :
NOP command enabled : Yes
READ BUFFER command enabled : Yes
WRITE BUFFER command enabled : Yes
Host Protected Area feature set enabled : No
DEVICE RESET command enabled : No
SERVICE interrupt enabled : No
Release interrupt enabled : No
Look-ahead enabled : No
Write cache enabled : Yes
PACKET Command feature set enabled : No
Power Management feature set enabled : Yes
Removable Media feature set enabled : No
Security Mode feature set enabled : No
SMART feature set enabled : Yes
SET MAX security extension enabled : No
Power-Up In Standby feature set enabled : No
Removable Media Status Notification feature set enabled : No
Advanced Power Management feature set enabled : No
CFA feature set enabled : No
[Word 88] Ultra DMA mode active : 1 (25 MB/s)
[Word 88] Ultra DMA mode supported : 6 (133.3 MB/s)
[Word 89] Time required for Security erase unit completion : Value not specified
[Word 90] Time required for Enhanced security erase completion : Value not specified
[Word 91] Advanced power management level value : 0
[Word 92] Master Password Revison Code : 00
[Word 127] Removable Media Status Notification feature set support : No
[Word 128] Security status :
Security level : High
Enhanced security erase supported : No
Security count expired : No
Security frozen : No
Security locked : No
Security enabled : No
Security supported : No


Comme l'indique IDEDrive 2.0, Windows reconnait le DOM en Ultra-DMA 1, encore une bizarrerie :








Enfin le DOM se comporte de manière complètement linéaire comme les CF. Les débits sont enfin maitrisés. Par contre ils sont en deçà de la carte Cisco qui pour l'instant reste en tête. Passons au SD...

Carte SD Samsung 16Go EVO



IDEdrive 2.0 :

SECONDARY MASTER :
List output by standard : ATA-5
[Word 0] General configuration :
Type of device : ATA
Removable media device : No
Not removable controller and/or device : Yes
[Word 1] Number of logical cylinders : 16383
[Word 3] Number of logical heads : 16
[Word 6] Number of logical sectors per logical track : 63
[Word 10-19] Serial number : CD1E0471
[Word 21] Cache size : 8 KB
[Word 23-26] Firmware revision : Rev 1.2
[Word 27-46] Model number : SINTECHI HighSpeed SD to CF Adapter V1.0
[Word 47] Maximum number of sectors per interrupt : 1
[Word 49] Capabilities :
Stanby timer values supported : No
IORDY supported : Yes
IORDY may be disabled : Yes
[Word 54] Number of current logical cylinders : 16383
[Word 55] Number of current logical heads : 16
[Word 56] Number of current logical sectors per track : 63
[Word 57-58] Current capacity in sectors : 31291392
[Word 59] Current number of sectors per interrupt : 1
[Word 59] Multiple sector setting is valid : Yes
[Word 60-61] Total number of user addressable sectors (LBA mode) : 31291392 (16.021 GB)
[Word 63] Multiword DMA transfer mode active : None
[Word 63] Multiword DMA transfer mode supported : 2 (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 64] Advanced PIO transfer mode supported : 4 (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 65] Minimum multiword DMA transfer cycle time per word : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 66] Recommended multiword DMA transfer cycle time : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 67] Minimum PIO transfer cycle time without flow control : 240 ns (8.3 MB/s)
[Word 68] Minimum PIO transfer cycle time with IORDY flow control : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 75] Maximum queue depth : 0
[Word 80] Major version number : Supports ATA/ATAPI-7
[Word 81] Minor version number : 1536
[Word 82-84] Command set supported :
NOP command supported : No
READ BUFFER command supported : No
WRITE BUFFER command supported : No
Host Protected Area feature set supported : No
DEVICE RESET command supported : No
SERVICE interrupt supported : No
Release interrupt supported : No
Look-ahead supported : No
Write cache supported : No
PACKET Command feature set supported : No
Power Management feature set supported : No
Removable Media feature set supported : No
Security Mode feature set supported : No
SMART feature set supported : Yes
SET MAX security extension supported : No
SET FEATURES subcommand required to spinup after power-up : No
Power-Up In Standby feature set supported : No
Removable Media Status Notification feature set supported : No
Advanced Power Management feature set supported : No
CFA feature set supported : Yes
READ/WRITE DMA QUEUED supported : No
DOWNLOAD MICROCODE command supported : No
[Word 85-87] Command set/feature enabled :
NOP command enabled : No
READ BUFFER command enabled : No
WRITE BUFFER command enabled : No
Host Protected Area feature set enabled : No
DEVICE RESET command enabled : No
SERVICE interrupt enabled : No
Release interrupt enabled : No
Look-ahead enabled : No
Write cache enabled : No
PACKET Command feature set enabled : No
Power Management feature set enabled : No
Removable Media feature set enabled : No
Security Mode feature set enabled : No
SMART feature set enabled : Yes
SET MAX security extension enabled : No
Power-Up In Standby feature set enabled : No
Removable Media Status Notification feature set enabled : No
Advanced Power Management feature set enabled : No
CFA feature set enabled : Yes
[Word 88] Ultra DMA mode active : 5 (100.0 MB/s)
[Word 88] Ultra DMA mode supported : 5 (100.0 MB/s)
[Word 89] Time required for Security erase unit completion : Value not specified
[Word 90] Time required for Enhanced security erase completion : Value not specified
[Word 91] Advanced power management level value : 0
[Word 92] Master Password Revison Code : 00
[Word 127] Removable Media Status Notification feature set support : No
[Word 128] Security status :
Security level : High
Enhanced security erase supported : No
Security count expired : No
Security frozen : No
Security locked : No
Security enabled : No
Security supported : No




Que dire ? Même en ATA-100 c'est toujours instable même si ça s'améliore bien (Minimum 9.9Mo/s).





Les débits en écriture d'ATTO avec les SD sont toujours aussi bons. De plus on ne retrouve plus cette latence de 30-50ms que l'on avait avant. Par contre en lecture la CF Cisco fait mieux. Sinon RAS.

Carte SD Transcend 64Go



IDEdrive 2.0 :

SECONDARY MASTER :
List output by standard : ATA-5
[Word 0] General configuration :
Type of device : ATA
Removable media device : No
Not removable controller and/or device : Yes
[Word 1] Number of logical cylinders : 16383
[Word 3] Number of logical heads : 16
[Word 6] Number of logical sectors per logical track : 63
[Word 10-19] Serial number : 0420191E
[Word 21] Cache size : 8 KB
[Word 23-26] Firmware revision : Rev 1.2
[Word 27-46] Model number : SINTECHI HighSpeed SD to CF Adapter V1.0
[Word 47] Maximum number of sectors per interrupt : 1
[Word 49] Capabilities :
Stanby timer values supported : No
IORDY supported : Yes
IORDY may be disabled : Yes
[Word 54] Number of current logical cylinders : 16383
[Word 55] Number of current logical heads : 16
[Word 56] Number of current logical sectors per track : 63
[Word 57-58] Current capacity in sectors : 123992064
[Word 59] Current number of sectors per interrupt : 1
[Word 59] Multiple sector setting is valid : Yes
[Word 60-61] Total number of user addressable sectors (LBA mode) : 123992064 (63.484 GB)
[Word 63] Multiword DMA transfer mode active : None
[Word 63] Multiword DMA transfer mode supported : 2 (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 64] Advanced PIO transfer mode supported : 4 (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 65] Minimum multiword DMA transfer cycle time per word : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 66] Recommended multiword DMA transfer cycle time : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 67] Minimum PIO transfer cycle time without flow control : 240 ns (8.3 MB/s)
[Word 68] Minimum PIO transfer cycle time with IORDY flow control : 120 ns (16.7 MB/s)
[Word 75] Maximum queue depth : 0
[Word 80] Major version number : Supports ATA/ATAPI-7
[Word 81] Minor version number : 1536
[Word 82-84] Command set supported :
NOP command supported : No
READ BUFFER command supported : No
WRITE BUFFER command supported : No
Host Protected Area feature set supported : No
DEVICE RESET command supported : No
SERVICE interrupt supported : No
Release interrupt supported : No
Look-ahead supported : No
Write cache supported : No
PACKET Command feature set supported : No
Power Management feature set supported : No
Removable Media feature set supported : No
Security Mode feature set supported : No
SMART feature set supported : Yes
SET MAX security extension supported : No
SET FEATURES subcommand required to spinup after power-up : No
Power-Up In Standby feature set supported : No
Removable Media Status Notification feature set supported : No
Advanced Power Management feature set supported : No
CFA feature set supported : Yes
READ/WRITE DMA QUEUED supported : No
DOWNLOAD MICROCODE command supported : No
[Word 85-87] Command set/feature enabled :
NOP command enabled : No
READ BUFFER command enabled : No
WRITE BUFFER command enabled : No
Host Protected Area feature set enabled : No
DEVICE RESET command enabled : No
SERVICE interrupt enabled : No
Release interrupt enabled : No
Look-ahead enabled : No
Write cache enabled : No
PACKET Command feature set enabled : No
Power Management feature set enabled : No
Removable Media feature set enabled : No
Security Mode feature set enabled : No
SMART feature set enabled : Yes
SET MAX security extension enabled : No
Power-Up In Standby feature set enabled : No
Removable Media Status Notification feature set enabled : No
Advanced Power Management feature set enabled : No
CFA feature set enabled : Yes
[Word 88] Ultra DMA mode active : 5 (100.0 MB/s)
[Word 88] Ultra DMA mode supported : 5 (100.0 MB/s)
[Word 89] Time required for Security erase unit completion : Value not specified
[Word 90] Time required for Enhanced security erase completion : Value not specified
[Word 91] Advanced power management level value : 0
[Word 92] Master Password Revison Code : 00
[Word 127] Removable Media Status Notification feature set support : No
[Word 128] Security status :
Security level : High
Enhanced security erase supported : No
Security count expired : No
Security frozen : No
Security locked : No
Security enabled : No
Security supported : No




Pff, besoin de commenter ?





Le retour de la latence à 17ms et des résultats bizarres....

PC de test n°4 - Génération 486



Description



  • PC Assemblé
  • UMC 33Mhz socket 3
  • Carte IDE VLB Promise PDC20230 - Jumper "Speed" positionné sur 5/5 (maximum)
  • 16Mo de RAM
  • Nappe IDE : 40 fils
  • Disquette de lancement Windows 95 - Version 4.10.1111
  • Configuration BIOS : Normal & LBA


Les screens





Bilan pour le PC 486



Compte tenu de la faible vitesse (maximum PIO4) les 3 types de supports testés se comportent tous de la même façon et affichent les mêmes chiffres. Et ce que ce soit en mode "Normal" (500Mo max) ou en mode LBA. Je n'ai pas testé la SD en 64Go sur ce PC.

  • Random access time : 1ms
  • Buffered read speed : 1.9Mo/s
  • Linear read speed : 1.9Mo/s


Conclusion générale



La carte CompactFlash



C'est la solution passe-partout qui fonctionne à tous les coups pour les 4 ordinateurs essayés. Revers de la médaille : le prix des cartes peut en rebuter plus d'un si on regarde le prix au Go.

Le DOM



Bonne surprise pour le modèle Kingspec acheté sur eBay. Les débits sont les mêmes que pour une carte CF. Par contre des résultats aléatoires en WDMA et Ultra-DMA33. Prévoir plutôt d'utiliser cela avec un contrôleur IDE ATA-66 ou supérieur. Aucun dysfonctionnement grave de constaté. Je recommande.

La carte SD



Difficile de faire une réelle conclusion concernant la partie SD car le contrôleur pouvant varier selon l'adaptateur que vous aurez chez vous, il se peut donc que les résultats présentés ne soient en rien identiques pour ceux qui n'auraient pas le même chip KTC FC1307A que moi. DiskSpeed32 montre quand même des résultats très aléatoires en terme de débit qui joue constamment au yoyo. De plus tout cela est gâché par une fiabilité déplorable (déconnexions, messages d'erreur). Résultats plus que mitigés pour ma part concernant ces cartes SD. Solution à réserver pour du stockage de documents mais pas pour le système.